PDA

View Full Version : Yellowstone Fishing Report


Pastor John
07-29-02, 09:50 AM
Just got back from a week in the Yellowstone area. I will be in a trance for several days, I’m sure…

Spent the week at Hubbard’s Yellowstone Lodge south of Emigrant – absolutely fantastic lodge: gourmet meals, excellent hosts, and great guides. Here are the details:

Arrived in Bozeman Monday at lunch, made it down to the lodge about 3pm. After tossing our bags into the room, we met our guide for the week and immediately launched one of the drift boats out on Merrell Lake, the lodge’s private trophy lake. The result? Four nice rainbows that smashed our damselfly dries; largest was about 20 inches.

Tuesday, we floated the Yellowstone fishing Prince nymphs (#12) trailing behind a Stimulator (#8). The river was rather off-color due to rains during the previous few days, but we still did well. Largest rainbow was 24 inches, and we caught about a dozen fish. We beached the boat at lunch and fished up Mill Creek and caught cutthroats from about every pool for about two hours. The cutts weren’t particularly fussy about what fly they would eat, but demanded a drag-free float. Fortunately, it took two or three botched casts to put them down, so we did pretty well.

Wednesday morning we fished Nelson’s Spring Creek for the most “technical” fishing of the week. These rainbows were tough to fool. They had seen every type of fly and tippet, and wanted specific flies. It took me a while to catch on, but we finally fooled four rainbows in the 16-18 inch range, using small Baetis dries. Tough fishing, but it was exciting to watch a rainbow evaluate my fly and drift and then make a commitment to take the fly. In the afternoon we fished Tom Miner Creek near the lodge for cutthroats – plenty of them and since it was mostly meadow we had great success with hopper and cricket patterns.

On Thursday we took off for Yellowstone NP and fished Slough Creek, Soda Butte Creek, and Tower Creek. Slough Creek yielded several rainbows and a couple of browns on a variety of flies, mostly Wulffs, Stimulators, and other attractor patterns in #10 and #12. Slough’s legendary reputation meant that we were about fifth in line to fish each pool, and it didn’t really have the wilderness feeling that I enjoy so much, although we did see plenty of bison and a moose. The highlight of the day was Tower Creek at the confluence with the Yellowstone; we caught 12-14 inch cutthroats all afternoon on various attractor patterns. I’m a real enthusiast of the cutthroat – their evaluative and gentlemanly rise is a real heart stopper; learning how to set the hook on these took some training. The water is so clear and the fish so visible that it’s easy to jump the gun on the hook set and miss the fish. But we got our share…

Friday we toured the park and ended up in West Yellowstone. Everything that you hear about the park is true – absolutely stunning scenery, lots of wildlife, and trout streams too numerous to count. The Madison, Firehole, and Gibbon were closed to fishing due to high stream temperature. Surprisingly, the other streams did not seem crowded; we saw and talked to plenty of other anglers, but there was lots of room for everyone with the abundance of water available.

Saturday we left West Yellowstone heading north and spent a half-day fishing the Gallatin inside the park. This was classic meadow fishing, all hoppers and crickets, and the river yielded an abundance of rainbows, browns, and cutthroats. By now I had learned that the way to fish meadow streams is to stay out of the water and spend lots of time on your knees (not necessarily praying, but trying to keep a low profile). These fish were not fussy about patterns, but demanded a drag-free float before they would take the fly. We put our share down due to clumsy walking or casting, but there were so many fish in the river that we ended up with more than a dozen in a couple of hours.

Can’t say enough about Hubbard’s Yellowstone Lodge! Although very expensive, the staff and accommodations were fantastic. Gourmet meals, great wines, and superb guides made this a very special vacation. Highly recommended – we’ve already booked our trip for next year…

John

Windknot
07-29-02, 11:39 AM
Terrific trip, Pastor John!

Once again, thanks for posting the info. These 3 minute vicarious vacations really perk up a dreary Monday!
Don

Emerger
07-29-02, 12:22 PM
Great report! I am headin out West in a few weeks and readin reports like this get me even more excited!

Flashback
07-29-02, 07:41 PM
Great Post Pastor John,

I was day dreaming the other day and reliving my trip of last year to the Yellowstone area. What a great place!

Your report took me there again.

Thanks,

FB

------------------
"I have laid aside business, and gone
a-fishing."

Izaak Walton



[This message has been edited by Flashback (edited 07-29-2002).]

TightLine
07-30-02, 02:11 PM
Pastor John

Ok I gotta ask b/c your trip is exactly what I want to do for my Dad.

What are you talking here, $$ wise?? Just give me a range... I hope that doesn't offend, not the intention. Just starting to save my nickles and dimes....

Pastor John
07-30-02, 02:42 PM
Tightline,

First, you have to understand that I took my non-fishing, but outdoors-oriented, wife with me and that we wanted the best that could be had in lodges, guides, and meals. That being said, we booked at Hubbard's Yellowstone Lodge. Our four-night, three guided day package was about $2800 and included all meals, guides, tips, etc. We spent two additional nights in local hotels on our own in Bozeman and Livingston. Not including souvenirs, we ended up with about a $4000 vacation once we paid for the rental car, meals, etc. I used Delta Frequent Flyer points to take care of the airfare.

Money very well spent, as the lodge, service, and guide were absolutely top-notch. We're planning on spending our whole vacation at Hubbard's next year if we can find a way to afford it...

John

trout whisperer
07-30-02, 05:18 PM
whisperer sez: i appreciate your trip report. it allowed me to open the scrapbook of my mind and relive a similar trip from years ago. thanks. regards, TW

TightLine
07-31-02, 09:47 AM
Pastor John

Ouch! I had better keep savin' those nickles and dimes. Thanks for the info., really appreciate it.

Drifter
07-31-02, 12:46 PM
Tightline,

Pastor John stayed in top-o-the-line accomadations, with guides and such, hence the $4000 price tag. I'm gonna do this one daay myself! There are ways to get by a lot cheaper if your're willing to make some sacrifices. I'm going to Yellowstone next week for ten days on an 800 dollar budget. Book a supersaver airfare in Feb or March, backpack into the backcountry (where some good fishing can be had) and sleep in a tent. Four nights in Park lodging (about 50 bucks a night, split the price with friends), and split car rental and it can be done.

So don't get discouraged and keep saving those pennies http://www.georgia-outdoors.com/ubbngto/wink.gif

Drifter

Pastor John
07-31-02, 01:23 PM
I "ditto" what Drifter is saying.

The waters of Yellowstone seem pretty easy to read, and there is lots of information available on which flies are working well from the local fly shops. Camping areas are abundant both inside and outside the Park. While we were there, only about half of the Park campsites were filling up before lunch, and a few did not fill at all. Outside of the Park in the National Forests, there are lots of places that are easy to find. Some of the most scenic campsites I have ever seen were on the banks of the Yellowstone River near Emigrant and only had one or two other tents at them.

Lots of hotel rooms of every price range are available in West Yellowstone, Bozeman, and Livingston.

It would be real tempting to camp in one of the primitive sites in the Gallatin NF and each coldcut sandwiches and hotdogs each day if it would enable me to go out there a couple of times during the year. When we go birdwatching in South Texas each year, we sleep in the tent and take our meals in local restaurants - it's a great way to have a budget trip without suffering.

John

[This message has been edited by Pastor John (edited 08-08-2002).]